Wednesday, 18 November 2026

Love That Show! Well, Maybe Not

Two shows spun off from Fibber McGee and Molly. McGee’s nemesis Throckmorton P. Gildersleeve was given his own comedy series in 1941. And it seems listeners bawled for Beulah, because she moved out and into her own programme in 1945.

The story goes that “Beulah” stood with her back to the studio audience. When she whirled around to face the mike, the audience exploded in laughs to discover Beulah was actually white actor Marlin Hurt (photo to right). I doubt the laughter came from anything but the result of goading of announcer Harlow Wilcox at the side of the stage. Surely audience members had been there before and knew it was a man. And network radio stages were set up with actors on the side in chairs facing the audience waiting for their cue.

Syndicated columnist John Crosby provides some background in his review on March 14, 1947, as he ticks off the radio domestic comedy clichés that filled the show.

RADIO IN REVIEW
By JOHN CROSBY
Beulah
Beulah is a radio character who has wandered restlessly from network to network and radio program to radio program like a lost sheep. Way back in 1939 the late Marlin Hurt originated Beulah a Negro maid with a perpetually distressed voice, on a comedy program called “Hometown. Unincorporated" on NBC. In 1943 Beulah drifted away from Hometown to become Fred Brady's girl friend in a program called “That's Life" also on NBC. Beulah's next job was opening the door at Fibber McGee's house, where she attracted considerable national attention, so much, in fact that the was given her own program as a summer replacement on CBS in 1945. The program was good enough to be continued as a regular winter show, which came to an end when Hurt died in 1946. There followed a 12-month search for a voice to replace Hurt's which ended when the program's producers signed Bob Corley, of Atlanta, who says he had a Negro mammy who sounded just like Beulah. Mr. Corley can he heard as Beulah on A. B. C., 9 p. m. E. S. T. Mondays.
* * *
I'm not entirely sure Beulah is worth all this explanation except as a bit of radio folklore showing how a radio character, once well under way, is perpetuated virtually forever. Beulah, as I recall, was pretty funny on the Fibber and Molly show, but then she didn't have to earn an entire half hour by herself. Beulah is now the harassed maid of the Jones family, which is composed of young Harry Jones and Aunt Alice Jones, who devote much of their time toward rescuing Beulah from the scrapes her boy friend Bill gets her into.
Bill is shiftless, scheming, grasping and everlastingly hungry and he is always on the verge but never quite marries Beulah, which provokes touch of the discussion in the Jones household. I'm afraid Bill also sounds a little too much like de Kingfish in Amos ‘n’ Andy.
“We gotta assume the canine."
"Assume the canine?”
“Put on de dog."
That's a fair sample of Bill's conversation. Recently Bill bought piece of land with Beulah's money. The property looked for a moment as if it might contain oil, but you and I knew all along that it wouldn't. This sort of by-play isn't enough to fill half an hour, so several other minor characters bob into the Jones household now and then with their problems, which are entirely unrelated to the rest of the plot. One of them is a man named Mr. Frank who sounds like Titus Moody and who exists in a state of total confusion. The act never varies much and goes something like this:
"Howdy do." This is Mr. Frank at the front door.
"Howdy do, Mr. Frank."
"What brings you here?"
“You de one dat rang de doorbell.”
“Uh ... I did? You mean I'm on the outside and you're on the inside?”
“That's right.”
“I thought this room was rather large. What's that?"
“That's the front hall mirror. That's your reflection in it."
“Oh, my! Gotta get that fixed."
* * *
There's also another character who stutters ba-hup, ba-hup and whistles, a device you can get tired of in an awful hurry. That about sums up Beulah. There really isn't anything the matter with it except that it isn't very funny and, at times, the writing seems a little aimless.
It’s also at times sentimental to an extraordinary degree. Unabashed sentiment seems to be a new trend in comedy programs. You find an awful lot of it in the new movies too. Maybe it's a sign of the times. For all I know we are headed into a postwar era in the popular arts, not at all like that of the last war, but like that after the Napoleonic wars which culminated in Queen Victoria.


Evidently, somebody didn’t “love dat man,” as Beulah might say. Hurt’s replacement was replaced later that year by Hattie McDaniel. While that wouldn’t help the scripts any, Paul Speegle of the San Francisco Chronicle praised her performances. “The big husky voice exudes warmth and friendliness,” he wrote. “Her comic touch is light and quick and sure. Her sense of timing is perfect.”

Beulah eventually spent three seasons on television, with various actresses in the role.

As for Crosby’s other columns that week:

Monday, March 10: Another sitcom, “McGarry and His Mouse.”
Tuesday, March 11: a CBS documentary on juvenile delinquency.
Wednesday, March 12: Lionel Barrymore’s “Mayor of Big Town.”
Thursday, March 13: Crooner Andy Russell (Toothy drawing to the right).

Click on any of the reviews to make them readable. Cartoons are by Alan Ferber of the Daily News in Los Angeles.

No comments:

Post a Comment