Sunday, 22 November 2026

Radio is Not TV For Benny

I’m not sure how young people these days get exposed to the great radio shows of the past. I’m part of the generation that came after those shows aired live (later transcribed) on the networks. One local station played old radio shows at night. It was inexpensive programming that filled an hour or more very easily (In this case, the announcer had played the discs while on the air in World War Two and kept them instead of returning them).

So it was there was still nostalgia for, and enjoyment of, Jack Benny, Fibber McGee and Molly, Edgar Bergen and many dramatic shows long after they first aired.

A columnist for the Lowell Sun delved into this, coincident to a Kraft Music Hall TV show from 1967 being repeated four years later. This appeared in the Sun, April 11, 1971. The headline “a myth” is a little ironic, since the writer gives readers a myth about Bill Paley cancelling the Benny CBS-TV show. If anyone cancelled it, it was Jim Aubrey.


A myth is as good as a smile for this fiddler
by WILLIAM K. SARMENTO
Sun Drama Critic
NEW YORK — It's hard to think of Jack Benny as 80 years old. It's even harder than thinking of him as 39! He is an American institution. In the late 1930's and early 40's, more people were tuned on radio every Sunday night at 7 to listen to Jack Benny than any other personality on the air. Not even the king of England's broadcast abdicating his throne "for the woman I love", nor President Roosevelt's declaration of war message to Congress drew as many listeners us the Benny half-hour show.
I open with that note of nostalgia today because on a Wednesday night NBC and Channel 4 will be repeating one of the few Jack Benny hours we get to see anymore. This one, called "Fiddler on the Loose" was telecast earlier this past season.
The last time I talked with Jack Benny was at a luncheon in Boston when he was appearing at the Carousel Theater in Framingham. This past week he has been in New York making the talk shows. And as often as he has been on them, each show vies to get him back first. Usually Johnny Carson wins out since Benny has been in the NBC fold since his famous squabble with CBS head William Paley who cancelled his weekly television series.
Benny is still philosophical about his image as a comedian. "As soon as you income famous, right away everybody wants to know if that's the real you," he commented. "On my last television special we tried to explore that idea but found that the man and the myth were so intwined that writing the sketches were difficult."
Benny explained that his humor, on the stage, radio and television always has been based upon a number of human frailties. These frailties Benny magnifies into ridiculous, and therefore humorous, proportions. He said, "I've spent most of my life developing humorous situations based on frailties or shortcomings which many people, myself included, possess. Maybe some people really are a bit stingy. Maybe I really am a little vain. What's wrong with trying to hang on to a buck or with thinking you're attractive to the opposite sex?"
Benny's backlog of humorous situations helped him make the successful transition from vaudeville to radio in the early Thirties. His first radio appearance was as a guest on the old Ed Sullivan Show. Yes smiling Ed had a radio show too.
"It was hard to get used to working on radio without the vaudeville audience", he recalled. "When I switched from radio to television 20 years ago, it was easy for me because it was just like going back to vaudeville. Actually the transition to television presented only one major problem. Some of the continuing gags he had developed on radio such as his aged Maxwell car or the underground vault where he stored his money, just didn't work so well. “They went great with sound effects on radio, but they didn't seem nearly so funny when you actually saw them on television," he explained. "Radio made you use your imagination; television shows it all to you".
Today recordings of the original Benny radio shows are collector's items and sell for a handsome price. And it you know someone who owns some of these historic broadcasts ask him to play one for you. You'll hear the sharp wit of Mary Livingston, the dumb wit of Dennis Day, the warm wit of Rochester, the ribald wit of Phil Harris and the dulcet tones of announcer Don Wilson. They were the Benny gang and television has never duplicated their success. Only Jack Benny goes on and on and on. It's nice to know somethings endure in this life.


I still enjoy the radio show better than the television shows, despite Benny going through an evolution on radio and his shows of the ‘50s not sounding like his shows of the ‘30s. And there were a number of radio shows that were re-worked for television (the Christmas department store shows being one example). Maybe Jack was right. There’s something to be said about using your imagination.

No comments:

Post a Comment