Day had been axed by NBC in July because he wouldn’t reduce his demand for $11,500 a week for his radio package. The same thing happened to Judy Canova, who was let go making $8,500 a week but told she could come back for $5,000. The big sponsorship money to pay the stars was moving faster and faster from radio into television. (Day, by the way, was getting $12,500 a week to sing in Las Vegas).
Jack Benny wasn’t a cheapskate like he played on the radio and Day wasn’t a naïve kid he portrayed. He proceeded to do what his mentor Benny had done several years earlier—played NBC and CBS off each other to land a new contract. He finally signed with the former, reported Variety on October 31, 1951. It was a TV-radio deal sponsored by NBC’s parent company, RCA. Not only did the contract let NBC plug its TV sets on the Day programme, it plugged Dennis’ records, which happened to be on the RCA label.
As the ink on the signed agreement dried, Day hit the promo circuit to push his coming TV show and fit in a mention for his new movie while he was at it. Hence this column by the Associated Press found in papers starting November 26, 1951 which also focused on Day’s savviness.
Dennis Day Prepares for Video DebutDay’s variety show debuted (or is that day-buted?) on February 8th, alternating weekly with Ezio Pinza. He tried to go the sitcom/songs route he had trod successfully on radio, with Verna Felton, Hanley Stafford and Kathy Phillips slotted as regulars. Day wasn’t so successful this time. On the East Coast, the premiere was opposite CBS’ Mama, which had a 40 share. Directors came and went. Writer Parke Levy bolted in late March; his final episode didn’t air in the East because of a blizzard in the Denver area cutting the NBC circuit. A show doctor was hired in May. The programme was replaced by a dramatic show in June and re-worked during the summer hiatus, returning in the fall.
By BOB THOMAS
HOLLYWOOD, Nov. 27. — (AP) — Eugene Denis McNulty [sic], better known as Dennis Day, portrays a dim-witted character on The Jack Benny radio show. If Day is dumb, many another show business personality would like to have the same brand of ignorance.
Here are some examples of Day's dumbness.
1. After years of biding his time, he landed himself a fat movie contract with Twentieth-Fox.
2. He is the only Fox player who has television rights.
3. He just signed a TV contract with NBC after weeks of bidding by that network and CBS.
The tenor is presently working in "The Girl Next Door" and will play a whimsical ax murderer in his next film. He has another film to follow that one, and so his TV show may not debut until the fall of 1952.
"They wanted me to start in January," he said. "But since I'm virtually doing three pictures a year instead of one, I may have to put the TV show off. Anyway, I'm in no hurry to get started. I've seen too many performers jump into TV before they were ready. Now the public is getting tired of them."
A few weeks ago, Day was in the enviable position of being wooed by the networks. Each day, top emissaries from NBC and CBS would visit him at the studio. Each call hiked the bidding price up a notch. Finally he accepted NBC's offer.
"It will be a variety show format," he said. "I made pilot films of both kinds—variety show and situation comedy along the lines of my air show. The situation comedy show turned out to be deadly. It just doesn't seem adaptable to TV."
Day indicated that he would concentrate on getting good writing for his show, "That is the most important element in a show's success," he said. "The trouble with a lot of the writing on TV today is that the writers are still thinking in terms of radio technique. They concentrate on gags. Fortunately there are a lot of new young writers coming who realize that TV depends on sight, not gags."
Day's own radio program is off the air and he said he might be giving up radio altogether.
"Jack (Benny) may drop his air show after this season," he reported. "Jack was very happy with his last TV show and thinks he has found the format that will work for him in TV. And I think he's right. He was playing the real Jack Benny and people loved him."
With Benny and others threatening to desert it, what will happen to radio?
"I guess it will be limited to recorded shows and music," Day observed. "Daytime radio will still be the same, but all the big nighttime shows will be dropping off. There's no money in radio any more."
Incidentally, the “ax murderer” movie role mentioned in the story never materialised and I have not been able to find out what it was supposed to be. However, Variety reported on March 13, 1952 that a deal was set for Day to play one of the leads in Gentlemen Prefer Blondes. Not only did it not happen, but a lead in Gentlemen Marry Brunettes announced in the Hollywood Reporter a year and three days later didn’t come to pass. In fact, Day never made another movie. Of course, mentor Benny had been out of the movie business by that time, too. Sticking to the small screen never hurt either of them.